Peanut butter and jam brown butter sponge cake

When the old Victoria sandwich won’t hit the spot, this peanut butter and jam brown butter sponge cake from Tarunima Sinha will NOT disappoint. It takes the classic American pairing to new heights with the addition of brown butter and a jam without too much sugar.

Tarunima Sinha is a self-taught baker and the founder of My Little Cake Tin. In 2019, Tarunima was featured in The Observer Top 50 Things in Food by Observer Food Monthly. Her cakes are known for their unique flavours and designs.

She says: “Here is a sponge cake with a few extra steps and enhanced flavours. None of the steps are difficult, but they are all important and when followed correctly result in a delicate and flavourful peanut butter and jam sandwich cake. The cake is a whisked sponge with brown butter, the buttercream is less sweet, light and fluffy with added peanut butter and cream. If you don’t want to make your own jam, you can use a good quality jam but this quick, roasted jam tastes so much better and fresher.”

  • Serves 8-10
  • Hands-on time 1 hour 45 min, plus cooling and chilling, oven time 55 min

Nutrition

Calories
711kcals
Fat
35g (18g saturated)
Protein
11g
Carbohydrates
87g (66g sugars)
Fibre
3.5g
Salt
0.6g

delicious. tips

  1. I find baking fruits the easiest way to make a small quantity of jam and compote; it means I don’t have to watch over it but I also prefer it because the flavours are fresher and more intense. You also need less sugar than normal jam. This is a quick jam, so make it in smaller quantities and store any leftovers in the fridge. It is delicious spooned over ice cream or yogurt with granola. Use any leftovers within a week.

    Easy swaps: if you make this cake out of strawberry and raspberry season, use defrosted frozen fruit instead for the best flavour.

  2. The brown butter keeps well in the fridge in a sealed container for a couple of weeks.

     

Subscribe

Fancy getting a copy in print?

Subscribe to our magazine