The ultimate cheese scones

Name: The ultimate cheese scones
Prep time: 10 min
Cook time: 14 min
Total time: 24 min
Yield: Makes 6
Cuisine: British recipes
Ingredients: 225g self-raising flour, plus extra to dust; 1 tsp baking powder; ½ tsp salt; ½ tsp cayenne pepper; 1½ tsp mustard powder; 55g chilled salted butter, cubed; 100g mature cheddar, finely grated, plus 50g grated; 60-100ml warmed mixture of whole milk and water, plus extra milk for brushing; You’ll also need…; Heavy-duty non-stick baking sheet; Round 6cm plain or crinkle pastry cutter

16 Reviews

Portion size: Makes 6
Hands-on time 10 minutes, oven time 14 minutes
Difficulty: easy

Vegetarian

Recipe by: Debbie Major

Save

These light and fluffy cheese scones are easy to make and topped with a toasted cheese crust. They make a delicious savoury treat for afternoon tea.

What makes a great scone: The scones should be well risen with a crisp crust topped with golden toasted cheese. The texture should be light and fluffy with a sharp hit of cheese flavour, inside and out.
The key ingredients: Use good quality to ensure your scones have that melt-in-the-mouth savoury flavour. Cayenne pepper and mustard powder give a spicy back-note that complements the cheese flavour.
Which cheese to use: A well flavoured cheese such as extra-mature cheddar, aged gruyère, a quality parmesan or a strong blue cheese is essential.

Prefer your scones sweet with jam and cream? Make our classic scones instead.

Before you start

You never knead a scone dough, as you want it to be only very lightly mixed. This is what gives them their crumbly texture.

Make sure your butter is fridge cold when you chop it and mix it into the flour. Cold fat in a dough will create a flakier texture once it’s introduced to the hot baking sheet. If you’ve got the time, put the cut scones in the fridge for 30 minutes before baking for maximum flakiness.

A few spoonfuls of finely chopped chives mixed into the dough gives the scones a pleasing garlicky flavour.

Join Extradelicious to unlock Cook Mode

Ingredients

225g self-raising flour, plus extra to dust
1 tsp baking powder
½ tsp salt
½ tsp cayenne pepper
1½ tsp mustard powder
55g chilled salted butter, cubed
100g mature cheddar, finely grated, plus 50g grated
60-100ml warmed mixture of whole milk and water, plus extra milk for brushing

You’ll also need…

Heavy-duty non-stick baking sheet
Round 6cm plain or crinkle pastry cutter

Join Extradelicious to unlock Cook Mode

Method

Put the baking sheet in the oven and heat it to 220°C/200°C fan/gas 7.
Meanwhile, sift the flour, baking powder, salt, cayenne pepper and mustard powder into a food processor. Add the cubed butter and process briefly until the mixture resembles very fine breadcrumbs. If you don’t have a food processor, put the dry ingredients in a large mixing bowl, add the butter and rub it in with your fingertips until the mixture resembles very fine breadcrumbs.
Tip the mixture into a large mixing bowl (if it’s not already in one), then mix in the 100g finely grated cheese.
Recipe continues after advertising adslot-recipe-4
Add the milk and water mixture to the bowl a little at a time (you may not need the full 100ml) and, using a dinner knife with a cutting motion, mix everything together quickly and evenly. Bring the mixture together quickly with your hands into a smooth ball, then put on a lightly floured work surface. Resist the temptation to knead it.
Gently press out the mixture using the heel of your hand to 2.5cm thick. Cut out 4 scones using your cutter. Gently press the offcuts together and cut out 2 more scones. Shape any remaining dough into a small disc (the cook’s perk!).
Brush the tops of the scones with milk and sprinkle with the remaining 50g grated cheese. Remove the hot baking sheet from the oven, put the scones on it, spaced well apart, then bake for 12-14 minutes until richly golden and cooked though.
Remove the scones from the oven and serve as soon as possible after baking, ideally spread with a little butter.

FAQs

Yes, the recipe already uses self-raising flour.

Butter, marmite, more cheese all work well. Or treat your scone like a mini sandwich with added ham, smoked salmon and cream cheese etc.

Serve them warm with butter or your favourite savoury toppings. Or as a side to winter soups.

Cheddar and gruyere make good choices or a combination of both.

Keep everything as cold as possible, mix/work the dough as little as possible and preheat the baking tray (this helps kickstart the baking for good rise and crusty base).

Yes, cook, cool and wrap well before freezing. Defrost at room temperature then reheat in a low oven for 5-10 minutes to refresh and warm through.

Nutrition

287kcals Calories
14.6g (8.8g saturated) Fat
8.5g Protein
29.5g (0.7g sugars) Carbs
1.5g Fibre
1.4g Salt

Quick wins & tips

Preheat the heavy-duty baking tray to get the raising agent working immediately. This gives the lightest, airiest scones with the crispest bases.

Use cold butter as it mixes in evenly without becoming greasy.

Warm the milk and water mixture to give the raising agent a boost.

Do everything with the lightest of touches – overworking the dough can make the scones tough. Using a dinner knife to mix in the liquid rather than your hands helps avoid overworking the mixture.

Press out the dough rather than rolling it to avoid stretching the dough or compacting it.

The deeper the dough, the taller your scones will be. When cutting them out the dough should almost come to the top of the cutter.

Don’t twist the cutter – press straight down for an even rise.

Don’t worry if the top of the dough isn’t perfectly smooth. It gets covered with cheese anyway.

You can warm day-old or defrosted scones briefly in a microwave or oven to bring them back to life.

Watch how to make them here:

Make Ahead

The scones are best eaten warm the day they’re made but will keep in an airtight container for up to 24 hours or in  the freezer for up to 1 month. Defrost thoroughly.

Cook smarter

What else to add to cheese scones
Swap half or all the cheddar with another firm cheese and add fresh or dried herbs, nuts, seeds, olives or chilli in step 3. Or try these variations:

Cheese and crispy bacon
Reduce the salt to 1/4 tsp. Griddle 100g streaky bacon rashers for 1-2 minutes on each side until golden. Roll up in kitchen paper and leave until crisp, then finely chop. Stir in with the cheese (step 3).

Parmesan, tomato and basil
Omit the mustard and use parmesan instead of cheddar. Dry 50g sun-blush tomatoes in kitchen paper, then chop coarsely. Add in step 3 with 15g shredded fresh basil.

Blue cheese and apple
Use 1/4 tsp salt, omit the cayenne and mustard, and replace the cheddar with dorset blue vinney, crumbled. Coarsely grate 1 large eating apple, then squeeze in your hands to remove excess juice. Stir into the mix in step 3 with the blue cheese, then use 50g blue cheese for the topping.

Rate and review

Rate

Reviews

rwharries@me.com

24th Mar 2023 a 9:29 am

Beautiful scones, but did find I needed to more milk. The mixture didn’t bind well with just 60mls. Other similar recipes have about double the amount of liquid. But it didn’t stop them being absolutely delicious!

detty30@icloud.com

8th Mar 2023 a 12:08 pm

These are beautiful . I changed my cheese from just cheddar to a mixture of provolone picante and cheddar . It makes them properly cheesey .

Diana Eastlake

10th Mar 2022 a 1:28 pm

The recipe should say 60 mils each of milk and warm water 120mls I read it as 60 mls in total and obviously it didn’t work.

Thea Everett

26th May 2022 a 10:29 am

Hi Diana. Thanks for your feedback! We’re going to re-test the recipe and get back to you! Thanks, Thea.

Elspeth Yates

6th Mar 2020 a 1:16 pm

Great recipe; can’t go wrong with Delicious Magazine! I did add a little parmesan after a recommendation from a friend and they were amazing!!

Fiona Logan

10th Mar 2020 a 11:27 am

Thanks for the feedback Elspeth, so glad you loved our cheese scones!